您目前使用的瀏覽器不支援HTML5,我們只能使用JScript呈現一些要素。 遺憾的是,在您的瀏覽器已關閉腳本功能。您必須打開腳本功能,才能完整顯示此頁面。
ringle-logo
Homo Identicus
A model of conflict resolution
Updated: 2021.12.07
6 min read · Intermediate

In going about our lives, we often tumble upon [1] emotionally charged conflicts. They surprise us with varying forms and intensity, but they are there — sometimes physical, and other times, passive-aggressive in nature. Such conflicts not only plague and amplify the gulf between individuals but also between groups, leading to warfare and international conflict.

On a personal level, relationship woes can be extremely frustrating because they usually involve resentment, pride, and fear. Unfortunately, there is no quick fix to protracted and emotionally charged disagreements. Caving in [2] to meet the demands of the counterpart will sow a seed of resentment in you; advancing your arguments will escalate the tension and impasse; avoiding discussion altogether will simply move the disagreement underground.

Thus, time and effort should be invested for two individuals to break free from adversarial patterns, and even after having a clear understanding of the nature of conflict, it takes much patience to heal from the damage done.

In the spirit of taking a careful approach, investigating the dimensions of conflicts can provide us with some hints. There are three models of human behavior that each focus on one dimension, explaining why we argue and what can lead to resolution.

The first dimension is that of reason, which is the primary focus of homo economicus (economic man). Underpinning the homo economicus model of human behavior is the assumption that people are motivated to find the most efficient way to have their interests met. Under this model, people lock horns to protect their interests, and as long as this goal is met, there is no conflict.

But homo economicus overlooks the fact that humans easily get invested in trivial matters. Emotions cut to the heart of our conflict, which is explained by the second dimension: homo emoticus (emotional man). This model explains our behaviors with emotion. Nevertheless, emotion doesn’t provide a satisfactory solution to conflicts since wounds have to heal before harmony is reached.

The third and final dimension, beneath reason and even beneath emotion is identity. Homo identicus is a behavioral model conceived by negotiation expert Daniel Shapiro. It is rooted in the principle “that human beings seek meaning in their existence.”

Understanding the role of identity in conflicts is fundamentally important. According to Shapiro, emotionally charged conflicts have their charge because they implicate aspects of identity. In other words, when you feel like your identity is under attack, you hunker down into self-defense mode and become blinded to the possibility of harmony. There are always emotional triggers that set you off, which are the moments where you feel like your existence has been attacked.

If our identities are at stake, emotionally charged conflicts seem to point to a grim conclusion. For harmony, one party must compromise their identity and become a different entity; otherwise, there is no bridging the gap between foes.

This hopeless diagnosis, nevertheless, is an illusion since identity is both fixed and fluid -- something negotiable. If identity is absolutely immutable, conflicts produce winners and losers. On the other hand, if identity is ever-changing, you cannot be held accountable for your actions, making the relationship pointless. How can someone be responsible for their behaviors in the past if they are now a completely different individual?

Therefore, understand what part of your identity is flexible. Identity comprises a list of characteristics that define yourself, but as much as they define you, you can define those characteristics. Therefore, when you reach an emotional deadlock, think about what aspects of your identity to prioritize. For example, if you are involved in a protracted and adversarial relationship as a CEO, it may not be the best idea to prioritize and ferociously protect your social identities outside your professional realm.

Another helpful approach is to “not take things personally.” Often, people interpret the words and actions of others in a way that implicates their identity. For someone who identifies themselves as a writer, a simple criticism of one line in their article can be received as a denial of the writer's identity. Don’t stretch [3] a line to define who you are as a writer; likewise, don’t stretch a single comment on a minor aspect into a wholesale attack on your noble identity.

As homo identicus, remember that preserving your identity and establishing harmony can be compatible goals.

*本教材是專爲使用Ringle學習英文的學員設計。