
Humans are rather susceptible [1] to bias. Indeed, bias usually helps streamline [2] our thinking, allowing us to quickly process lots of information and make sense of the world. As part of this processing, people, places, and things are categorized and grouped in manners that make sense to us, and upbringing [3] or culture influences this processing. Bias is useful in some cases, but, in the workplace, and in other situations, it can be harmful.
Take the case of a resume study wherein science professors across the US were randomly selected to evaluate one of two fictitious resumes. The professors then subsequently rated the applicant based on judgments of competence. One applicant consistently received lower ratings on competence, despite the fact that the two resumes were identical, except for the names of the applicants. “Jennifer” was perceived as less competent than “John.”
Dealing with unconscious biases is difficult, especially when ingroup and outgroup thinking afflicts everyone. In-group biases refer to an individual giving preferential treatment to people in his social or identity group. Out-group bias is characterized by negative stereotypes and discrimination against groups of people who don’t share one’s identity. Unfortunately, studies have shown that mandatory unconscious bias training in workplaces can actually increase defensiveness in some while having little impact on people’s behavior.
Awareness opens up the door to new conversation, but where, then, do we go from here?