Browser not supported. Please use Google Chrome or Microsoft Edge to access Ringle.
ringle-logo
Politics
Why is the British Parliament So Rowdy?
Tradition, throng, and task
Updated: 2022.09.21
3 min read · Advanced
material_image

In the wake of [1] Boris Johnson’s resignation as the United Kingdom’s Prime Minister, a flurry of videos appeared on social media showing the British Parliament (specifically, the House of Commons) in a particularly rambunctious [2] state. Given the calamity [3] of Johnson’s abrupt but expected departure, one may reasonably assume that Parliament was so chaotic because of it. However, Parliament is usually dramatic, with a series of customs and layouts encouraging confrontation.

In the House of Commons, the democratically-elected lower chamber of Parliament, members of the government sit on one side of the room, with members of the opposition party on the other. This design invites confrontation; there’s nowhere to hide from the scrutinizing eyes of your opponents. The House of Commons also has only 427 physical seats, yet 650 members of Parliament (commonly referred to as MPs), so it gets crowded. One side of the room is separated from the other by two sword lengths to protect against spontaneous duels, of course.

The debate style is largely one of custom rather than statute. According to Parliament, it “has traditionally been one of cut-and-thrust; listening to other Members' speeches and intervening in them in spontaneous reaction to opponents' views.” These reactions are usually shouts of “hear, hear!” or the waving of papers, but seldom claps, which are traditionally avoided.

A contributing factor to Parliament’s organized disorder is the height of its responsibilities. The House of Commons challenges the activities of the government and scrutinizes leaders, such as the Prime Minister, in fierce debates known as question period. It also creates new laws (subject to the inspection of the House of Lords) and approves government spending and new taxes. They are the sole authority on the lattermost duty, differentiating themselves from the US Congress, where both chambers must pass new laws and taxes before the President signs them into law.

To outsiders, the rowdiness may seem like a distraction and detriment [4]. However, it’s important to recognize every political jurisdiction has a distinct method of madness suitable for its political problems. Some British commentators even think that rowdiness is essential to their democracy.

So, rather than viewing Parliament’s loud spectacle as a failure of democratic government, think of it more as a response to centuries of well-regarded tradition, the House’s tight physical dimensions, and the weight of extreme responsibility.

*This material is designed for the exclusive use of Ringle students on the Ringle platform.